INJURY?

(570) C-A-L-L-D-L-P

Forced Arbitration in Nursing Homes: How Facilities Try to Strip Away Your Right to a Jury Trial

When news broke that a grieving husband’s wrongful death lawsuit against Walt Disney World was almost derailed because of terms of service buried in a Disney+ subscription, it exposed the reality of the American legal system: forced arbitration. Some people associate fine print with streaming apps or cell phone contracts, and this exact same tactic is quietly used every day in Pennsylvania nursing homes. During the exhausting process of admitting an aging parent into a care facility, families are handed stacks of paperwork containing mandatory arbitration agreements. Signing these clauses signs away a right to hold a facility accountable before a public jury, shifting life or death disputes into private rooms.

The Hidden Justice System in Long-Term Care

            Going off the NACA, in simple terms, forced arbitration means:

  • You give up your right to go to court: To get a job/buy a product, you must agree that you will not sue the company if a problem arises
  • A private person decides your case: Instead of a judge and jury in a public courtroom, a private arbitrator decides who wins
  • Decision is final: If you lose, you cannot appeal the decision. You are stuck with whatever the arbitrator decides
  • No team lawsuits: You are not allowed to join a class action lawsuit with other people who were harmed by the same company
  • It is kept secret: Unlike public court cases, the process and the results are kept strictly private

Forced arbitration replaces public courtrooms with private proceedings by paid arbitrators instead of judges and local juries. As Brendan Ballou highlighted in The New York Times, while consumers win up to 89% of the time in public courts, they win as few as 21-33 percent of cases before major private arbitration providers. In a nursing home context, this dynamic strongly favors the facility. Arbitration proceedings are kept secret, shielding negligent nursing homes and preventing other families in the community from learning about dangerous patterns of understaffing or physical abuse. Because repeat corporate defendants bring business to these private arbitration firms, the system creates a conflict of interest that works against vulnerable residents.

How Nursing Homes Trick Families into Signing

Nursing home operators understand that family members are under immense stress during the admissions process, often transitioning a loved one directly from a hospital after a sudden stroke or severe illness. Admissions coordinators routinely slide arbitration agreements into massive admission packets, framing them as “standard paperwork” or misleading families into believing that signing is required to secure a bed or receive Medicaid covered care. Under federal regulations, nursing homes are prohibited from denying admission or care whether a resident signs a pre-dispute arbitration agreement. Yet, facilities continue to use high-pressure tactics, obscure legalese, and rushed intake processes to trap unsuspecting families into waiving their fundamental legal rights.

Can You Challenge a Nursing Home Arbitration Clause?

            If your loved one suffered severe harm after an arbitration clause was signed, do not assume that your legal options are exhausted. In PA, skilled personal injury attorneys challenge and invalidate these agreements in court on strong legal grounds. An example is if the resident suffered from dementia or lacked the legal capacity to understand the contract at the time of signing, the agreement may be declared void. And if a family member signed the paperwork without holding a financial and legal Power of Attorney that granted them authority to waive court rights, the clause cannot be enforced against the resident. In lots of cases, separate wrongful death claims brought surviving family members cannot be forced into arbitration because the family members never individually signed away their own rights to sue.

How DLP Law Fights Corporate Neglect and Forced Arbitration

Nursing home corporations rely on arbitration clauses to bury evidence of neglect and avoid facing a jury of local citizens. At DLP Law, our nursing home abuse attorneys refuse to let negligent facilities hide behind fine print and unfair corporate agreements. We scrutinize every page of admission paperwork and fight to bring your case into the light of a public trial. If your parents or relative suffered from bedsores, malnutrition, medication errors, etc. in a long term care facility, we have the resources and trial experience to hold the corporate owners fully accountable.

Injury? Call DLP! (570) C-A-L-L-D-L-P.

Links:

https://www.justice.org/resources/research/the-truth-about-forced-arbitration

INJURY? (570) C-A-L-L-D-L-P

570-225-5357

We’re Here For You Schedule a Free Consultation Today

From start to finish, we will aid you throughout the legal process.

Free Initial Consultations

Start with a no-cost consultation to discuss your case and explore your options.

A Track Record of Success

Proven results backed by years of successful outcomes for our clients.

Backed by Decades of Legal Experience

Trusted guidance built on decades of proven legal expertise.

Millions Recovered For Our Clients

Millions secured in compensation for clients through dedicated legal advocacy.

Español

Step 2 of 6

Who was in the accident?

Select 1 option

Who was at fault?

Select 1 option

Were you insured at the time of the accident?

Select 1 option

Let's get in touch

For a free consultation

How would you like to be contacted?

Select 1 option