You pay your insurance premiums on time every month, trusting that if disaster strikes, your carrier will be there to protect you. But many policyholders discover the hard way that their insurance company is more interested in protecting itself rather than fulfilling its contracts or promises. If an insurer delays, lowballs, or denies a claim without justification, then it is not just poor customer service. It is a legal violation also called “insurance bad faith.” Understanding your rights under Pennsylvania law is essential for fighting back when your own insurance company turns against you.
Defining Insurance Bad Faith Under Pennsylvania Law
The relationship between an insurer and a policyholder is governed by a strict duty of good faith/fair dealing. An insurance company can be held liable for acting in bad faith (Title 42). To prove a bad faith claim in court, a policyholder must show two key elements. First, that the insurer did not have a reasonable basis for denying or delaying policy benefits. Second, that the insurer knew or disregarded its lack of a reasonable basis. This means you must show that the denial wasn’t just a simple mistake, but a conscious disregard for your rights.
Recognizing the Tactics: Common Examples of Bad Faith
Insurance companies utilize teams of adjusters and attorneys trained to minimize payouts. Recognizing their tactics is the first step in protecting your claim. Common examples of bad faith are:
- Failing to conduct a thorough investigation: entirely ignoring evidence provided by the policyholder. They are misrepresenting the actual language of the policy to justify a denial.
- The “Lowball Offer”: an insurer offers a settlement amount significantly lower than what the claim is worth, hoping the victim will accept it out of financial desperation following an accident.
The Difference Between a Coverage Dispute and Bad Faith
Not every denied claim means bad faith. A standard coverage dispute usually centers on a genuine disagreement on how a policy exclusion or definition is interpreted. If an insurance company conducts a thorough investigation and is unbiased, their actions are usually considered reasonable (even if a judge later rules that the claim should be paid). Bad faith happens when the underlying process is intentionally flawed or biased to purposely avoid paying what is owed.
Holding Insurers Accountable: Damages You Can Recover at DLP Law
When a massive insurance corporation acts in bad faith, the financial and emotional toll on a family can be devastating. At DLP Law, our attorneys have a history of holding these companies accountable. Victims can recover the original value of their claim, plus interest calculated at a prime rate. Also, courts can assess court costs and attorney fees against the insurer to punish their behavior. If you believe your insurance company is mistreating you, our team is here to level the playing field.
Injury? Call DLP! (570) C-A-L-L-D-L-P.
Links:





